Skip to main content

People's participation is usually regarded a sine qua non for the success and sustainability of development projects. Yet in practice, it raises a number of questions.

TitleThe rhetoric of participation re-examined : the state, NGOs and water users at Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication1994
AuthorsAhmed, S
Paginationp. 3-16 : 5 fig., 1 tab.
Date Published1994-01-01
Keywordscommunity participation, consumers, government organizations, india ganga river, india uttar pradesh varanasi, non-governmental organizations, rivers, sdiasi, sdipar, sdiwrm, surface water pollution
Abstract

People's participation is usually regarded a sine qua non for the success and sustainability of development projects. Yet in practice, it raises a number of questions. Who are the people? Why is their participation sought, and how or at what level, is such participation desired? This paper seeks to examine the rhetoric of participation in the implementation of the Ganga Action Plan (GAP) at Varanasi, in the north-eastern State of Uttar Pradesh, India. Launched in 1985, the GAP is the first major attempt to systematically control and monitor the pollution of a significant river in the country. In addition, it is claimed to be a people's programme because of the powerful and deep-seated cultural and religious meaning associated with the Ganga. Varanasi, however, is indicative of its failure to deliver this promise - the GAP is only acceptable to authority because it does not challenge the existing institutional order, and its participatory content is symbolic rather than substantive. Non-governmental organizations, traditionally viewed as intermediary actors between the micro and macro levels, work within the socio-political framework of the city. In the process, water user groups such as washermen who derive an economic livelihood from washing clothes in the Ganga, are literally excluded from the definition and process of participation. [Author's abstract]

Notes42 ref.
Custom 1205.1, 822

Locations

Disclaimer

The copyright of the documents on this site remains with the original publishers. The documents may therefore not be redistributed commercially without the permission of the original publishers.

Back to
the top